Arizona Stewards Find No Rule Violations, Take No Action In Creative Plan Case - Horse Racing News | Paulick Report

Arizona Stewards Find No Rule Violations, Take No Action In Creative Plan Case

Creative Plan, shown the day of his veterinary assessment at Jenny Earhart’s Premier Equine Rehab

Roughly ten days after the sad story of Creative Plan was received with shock and disgust by many in the racing world, stewards in Arizona have concluded their investigation.

According to a spokesman for Arizona's racing commission, no action will be taken against licensees involved in the horse's care in his last months of life.

“The stewards interviewed multiple individuals regarding Creative Plan and determined no rule was broken surrounding this case,” wrote Maxwell Hartgraves via email. “That said, the Division of Racing continues to evaluate this matter and find improvements to horse racing in Arizona.”

Creative Plan was euthanized Feb. 11 after a veterinarian determined he had injuries too severe to be rehabilitated.

Creative Plan was claimed in his last start at Turf Paradise on Jan. 7, where veterinarians conducting a pre-race examination noted the horse as “racing sound with a choppy jog.” Curt Ferguson, the trainer who claimed the horse said he came out of the race “obviously lame” but not vanned off, and that the horse's previous trainer acknowledged the horse's condition was not unusual for him following a race. Ferguson gave Creative Plan to an employee, believing the employee would rehabilitate the horse for a racing career. Instead, the employee took the horse to a nearby livestock auction and refused to sell him to a group of aftercare advocates, instead abandoning the horse on site. The underbidder on the horse at that sale was allegedly a dealer who has been known to purchase horses for slaughter.

At the time of his death, the horse had an injury to the suspensory ligament so severe that pastern had dropped considerably. Veterinarians who reviewed a copy of a radiograph taken of the same leg in January also noted multiple chronic areas of damage and injury to the suspensory and to the bones in that leg.

Read our complete reporting on Creative Plan here.

Subsequent to the case, Turf Paradise has re-instituted a policy prohibiting licensees from selling a horse for slaughter.

In a meeting of the Arizona Racing Commission on Feb. 15, commissioners and staff indicated the track could see a few reforms aimed at improving safety, including implementing third-party furosemide administration and unspecified changes to claiming rules. Dr. Sue Gale, one of two veterinarians responsible for examining horses pre-race at Turf Paradise, also requested more help in flagging horses in need of further scrutiny based on identified risk factors.

At the time of that Feb. 15 meeting, the fatality rate for the current Turf Paradise meet was 2.98 per 1,000 starts — more than twice the national average of 1.41 per 1,000 starts in 2020.

Paulick Report Icon

Receive daily headlines, breaking news alerts, promotions, and much more!

Become An Insider

Support our journalism and access bonus content on our Patreon stream

Learn More